This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Find out more here     

TripAdvisor moves beyond review reliability

Bookmark and Share

 

07 July 2011
By Stacey Mieyal Higgins
News Editor-International
stacey@hotelnewsnow.com

REPORT FROM THE U.S.—As the role of social media evolves, there have been a few recurring themes that seem to garner the lion’s share of attention from hoteliers. Among those issues, dealing with the guest feedback on sites such as TripAdvisor has been a particularly popular concern.

TripAdvisor recently launched a series of regional Master Classes to address hoteliers’ concerns and misconceptions. The education project has been successful, according to Brian Payea, head of industry relations for the company, who leads portions of the classes.

Brian Payea
head of industry relations
TripAdvisor
“We bring an awful lot of information to the audience and we bring a lot of resources out for them to use,” he said. “We definitely want to correct any misinformation … fill in some gaps. There are lots of people who have limited knowledge about what we’re all about.”

But there always seems to be a few hotel owners/operators who believe they are victims of fake reviews. What about them?

“We can’t go into a tremendous amount of detail,” Payea said. “We have a zero-tolerance policy for fraud. We have many resources. It’s a pretty sophisticated operation with a huge number of engineers to work on the computer-based tools to put against that, developing automated filters and resources to look at that huge amount of information and look at clues on those 45 million reviews.”

Payea said there also is a team that investigates “any hint” that information should come down.  He declined to say how many people are on this team or how many reviews had been taken down because of suspected fraud, stating the need for confidentiality in these matters.

He added TripAdvisor reviews correlate closely to customer satisfaction tracked through other channels, according to anecdotal evidence from hotels.

Furthermore, Market Metrix released study findings Tuesday (http://www.hospitalitynet.org/news/4052085.html) that indicate “the mean scores of hotels track very consistently and closely between TripAdvisor and the (Market Metrix Hospitality Index).”

The study concluded reviews for a particular hotel are a reliable measure of average customer satisfaction of that hotel, given adequate sample size. The variability of scores was found to be slightly greater among TripAdvisor hotels.

For the study, customer evaluations for 67 hotels were directly compared using TripAdvisor and MMHI data for 12 months.

“The concept of being suspect of feedback is almost a little passé,” Payea said during an interview last week. 

Indeed, despite the hotelier gripes about negative feedback, TripAdvisor asserts more than 250 companies feature its content, including destination marketing organizations, hotel chains, airlines and online travel agencies. And more than 20,000 websites use TripAdvisor badges, such as “Recommended On,” “Bravo!” and the “What's Nearby?” widget.

More on Master Classes
TripAdvisor hosted five classes in 2010 and has a full roster for the summer.

“We invite as many as we can in the industry to come in and hear and participate in engagement stations and talk one-to-one with people from all parts of the company—the product team, customer service, sales team. They’re all talking about ways (owners) can add information to their site to market to this audience,” Payea said of the classes.

Upcoming Master Class dates and locations:
•    Montreal: 26 July
•    Jakarta, Indonesia: 26 July
•    Bali, Indonesia: 28 July
•    Bangkok: 2 August
•    Phuket, Thailand: 4 August
•    Chicago: 9 August
•    Dallas: 30 August

Bookmark and Share





7 Comments
Show All

21 June 2012 at 10:13 PM Central Time
In response to: TripAdvisor moves beyond review reliability
DML commented:
I posted a review on Trip Advisor that contained unfavourable information that my colleague staying there had shown me lots of bug bits on the exposed parts of her body and that these bites were lined up in a row, six inches apart. This is the hallmark of bedbug bites. All of my review was dispassionate and factual. Guess what, after receiving one "helpful" rating the day after it was posted, a soon after that this review is no longer on the site. I now consider Trip Advisor to be unreliable because the negative information that we would like to see, along with the positive, seems to be systematically deleted.

21 July 2011 at 6:30 AM Central Time
In response to: TripAdvisor moves beyond review reliability
Ben Bishop commented:
I use TripAdvisor and I post there. I judge other reviews by the number of posts and the written comments. Ratings can be gamed but the content of the reviews tells me the story.

15 July 2011 at 12:51 PM Central Time
In response to: TripAdvisor moves beyond review reliability
anonymous commented:
TripAdvisors review cannot be reliable until they cooperate with the hotel industry. For example, when a guest filled out a review complaining about the hotel wants to charge a different rate for switching my reservation from a low season rate to high season, TripAdvisor should validate the review before posting it. Another clear example is that competitors may trashing each other; and they can create e-mail to post bad or good reviews.

13 July 2011 at 3:31 PM Central Time
In response to: TripAdvisor moves beyond review reliability
Guest 1 commented:
I second Susan's comment. More openness and transparency from the subsidiary of a public company. What is this "Market Metrix Hospitality Index"? I have never heard of it. Just because they say something, doesn't make it so. Furthermore, who chose their study's 67 hotels? Tripadvisor. Another note would be that most statisticians usually agree that you need 100 samples to be relevant.



Login
Or enter a name to post your comment:

Post Your Comment

(4000 charcters max)

Comments that include links or URLs will be removed to avoid instances of spam. Also, comments that include profanity, lewdness, personal attacks, solicitations or advertising, or other similarly inappropriate or offensive comments or material will be removed from the site. You are fully responsible for the content you post. The opinions expressed in comments do not necessarily reflect the opinions of HotelNewsNow.com or its parent company, Smith Travel Research and its affiliated companies. Please report any violations to our editorial staff.



Follow HotelNewsNow.com on Twitter Subscribe to the HotelNewsNow.com RSS Feed Connect with HotelNewsNow.com on LinkedIn