Winning in the procurement process
 
Winning in the procurement process
21 JULY 2011 8:09 AM

The procurement agent must act as the liaison between the interior designer and more than 2,000 global vendors to find the real win/win solutions.

 

If my experience heading a global furniture, fixtures and equipment and operating supplies and equipment purchasing firm with active projects in more than 20 countries has taught me anything, it’s that every client in every country wants to “win” in their project.

As consultants, we have to be sensitive that each client may define “winning” in a slightly different manner. Understanding how they do so is essential to the success of every project. Whether a new build or renovation, everyone on the team wants to feel a sense of accomplishment and a “job well done” upon completion. Just like all the pre-competition training required to win an Olympic sporting event, the ability to create the winning recipe for every project starts early in the procurement process.

The performance parameters
In order to get started down the path of winning for the client, one must always ask about the project’s budgetary and scheduling goals. Although it is an obvious place to start, a recent industry purchasing survey noted that 25% of purchasing agents did not know their project’s budget before being engaged. No consultant should ever start a project that way.

 

Alan Benjamin

When in the RFP stage of a project, an understanding of the project’s high-level budget and schedule is essential to understanding the procurement consultant’s ability to deliver what the client needs, as well as the systems, reporting, accounting and human resources needed to make it happen. Every project—even the most high-end, “6-star-ultimate” hospitality projects—are bound by limitations in both schedule and budget. Furthermore, every project will have a slight, or in some cases, extreme propensity to focus on schedule or budget as the client’s definition of the “win” for that project.

If a project has to be completed by a critical, non-moving date—such as a large convention or a special, one-time event business demand generator that the hotel cannot lose—the team has to find a way to make it happen, period. Even when there is not a large one-time source of revenue to harvest, no project can ever afford to suffer from displacement of revenue caused by a delayed opening due to late FF&E and operating supplies and equipment deliveries.

Around the world and in every market and segment, the shelf life of a hotel room is the same: 24 hours. Renting the room Tuesday does not make up for the fact that Monday’s revenue is lost forever. After what is often more than five years in the development, financing and construction process, the FF&E and operating supplies and equipment procurement is the last step of a carefully choreographed effort to get the project open and generating a return for its investors. While the budget is often smaller at the implementation stage of the FF&E and operating supplies and equipment part of the project due to over runs and issues upstream of the FF&E and operating supplies and equipment area, the schedule usually never moves, unless the owner wants to accelerate the opening. For every project there is the “time dictator” and the “money dictator,” and each has their role in our decision making.

Active listening
Once the high-level performance parameters are set, one must listen to the client and listen to the project. While listening to the client is always key in every business relationship, listening to the energy of the project itself and working with the entire project team as a group to define the largest possible win for the client is essential.

One of the keys to active listening is to not assume the procurement solutions for a particular project are the same as the last project of a similar brand or project type. In other words, keep the creative process going. Ask questions beyond the initial and obvious product solutions. See if there is an innovative technology that you have not used before. And simply stay curious. All these elements are essential to the process to deliver a superior solution.

An area requiring innovation from the entire capital expenditures team, and universal to many renovation projects around the world, is the disruption of the “normal” CapEx cycles caused by recent economic turmoil. It now may be necessary to work on “half-cycle” solutions, such as a partial soft goods package that will allow the hotel to improve its competitive position from a product standpoint. The “half-cycle” solution will then allow the property to proceed through its next hard goods renovation cycle without replacing the new soft goods, prior to them being expired at the end of their normal life cycle.

Appeasing the dictators
Working as a critical member of the owner’s team, the procurement agent can be the key to facilitating a win for the owner in every project. To appease the “money dictator,” one can always cut the budget by shortening the life cycle of a product, cutting overall quality, buying a product that looks similar but is really inferior in many aspects. To appease the “time dictator,” one can also pay extreme expediting charges, for both manufacturing and shipping.

Of course, neither of these proposed “solutions” will result in an overall win for the owner. It is the role of the procurement agent to act as the liaison between the interior designer and more than 2,000 global vendors to find the real win/win solutions for the entire team that will yield the largest, most tangible and easily definable win for the owner.

Alan Benjamin (abenjamin@benjaminwest.com), a member of the International Society of Hospitality Consultants, is president and founder of the leading FF&E and OS&E procurement firm in the world, Benjamin West, based out of Boulder, Colorado. In addition to the Boulder office, Benjamin West has offices in Chicago, Dallas, Hong Kong and London, is currently working on projects in over 20 countries and deploys over US $1M per day as a fiduciary agent for its clients.

The opinions expressed in this column do not necessarily reflect the opinions of HotelNewsNow.com or its parent company, Smith Travel Research and its affiliated companies. Columnists published on this site are given the freedom to express views that may be controversial, but our goal is to provoke thought and constructive discussion within our reader community. Please feel free to comment or contact an editor with any questions or concerns.

 

1 Comment

  • Alexandra Gibson July 26, 2011 10:05 AM

    This is very well put- asking the right questions is so important. That is the only way to truly understand what the client expects. Regarding the hard deadlines communicated by clients, I would take it one step further and say that the communication needs to be a conversation. Often, it is the purchasing agent's job to educate the team on realistic timelines early in the process. As much as we want to meet the client's expectations, sometimes we have to be the bearer of bad news early to save the dime for everyone at the end. Alexandra Gibson Aspen Associates aspenpurchasing.com

Comments that include blatant advertisements or links to products or company websites will be removed to avoid instances of spam. Also, comments that include profanity, lewdness, personal attacks, solicitations or advertising, or other similarly inappropriate or offensive comments or material will be removed from the site. You are fully responsible for the content you post. The opinions expressed in comments do not necessarily reflect the opinions of Hotel News Now or its parent company, STR and its affiliated companies. Please report any violations to our editorial staff.