Economist: Hoteliers should prepare for a downturn
Economist: Hoteliers should prepare for a downturn
05 JULY 2018 7:31 AM

Bernard Baumohl, chief global economist for the Economic Outlook Group, warns there are several worrying signs for the fate of the overall economy and hoteliers would be wise to plan for a recession.

HOUSTON—While the outlook shared by many hoteliers has remained relatively upbeat as the hotel industry has enjoyed a prolonged up-cycle, at least one economist warns that the good times probably won’t last much longer.

Speaking during HSMAI’s 2018 Revenue Optimization Conference, Bernard Baumohl, chief global economist for The Economic Outlook Group, said there are reasons for pessimism at the moment.

“The concern I have is we’re beginning to see the seeds of a much more significant slowdown in 2019 and 2020,” he said.

Baumohl admitted though that recent history has proven the difficulty of making economic projections in an unpredictable environment.

“Right now we’re in a pivotal moment in U.S. and world economic history,” he said. “There will be a lot of textbooks written about what’s happening right now. It’s really extraordinary. It’s difficult for economists to project what spending will be over the next two years, and part of that is that the models we use are incredibly ill-equipped to handle the impulsive decision-making and convulsions taking place right now.”

He said at the beginning of the year the global economy looked like a well-oiled machine, spurred to further growth by the U.S. tax cuts put into place in late 2017. But that changed when “someone threw a massive wrench” into that machine in the form of a rash of tariffs incited by U.S. President Donald Trump.

“For all practical purposes, we’re now in a trade war, and that will obviously have an impact on the economy,” Baumohl said.

Signs in the market
In addition to back-and-forth tariffs, other potential bad omens for the economy include the ongoing investigation into Russian interference in U.S. elections and record levels of both household and government debt.

Baumohl said the level of household debt can be a particularly worrying sign for an industry like hotels that rely heavily on discretionary spending.

“If consumers decide at some point to reduce indebtedness, by definition that means there is less money available for spending,” he said. “That’s something to watch carefully.”

He also said a business spending boom that many in the travel industry had hoped would come from the U.S. tax cuts hasn’t materialized.

“We’re disappointed with what we’ve seen,” he said. “We haven’t seen the rebound everybody was talking about.”

He noted many companies have been reticent to spend freely during times of so much uncertainty, and major publicly traded companies have instead opted to return capital to shareholders with the first quarter of 2018 seeing “a record amount of stock buybacks.”

“In the month of May alone, we saw the most announced plans for stock buybacks ever,” he said. “Clearly companies are not yet confident and don’t see sufficient return on investment at this juncture to commit to capital spending.”

In addition to those specific signs, he said the average rebound time following a recession is roughly five years, and the U.S. economy has “been going nine full years of growth.”

How hoteliers can react
Baumohl said hoteliers—specifically revenue managers—would be wise to start preparing for the worst, as it is his expectation that there is a recession coming in the near future.

“It’s time that revenue managers start preparing this year to consider what their strategy is (for a downturn),” he said. “We do believe the possibility (of a recession) is likely over the course of the next two years.”

He said that timeline could be even more condensed than that in the worst-case scenario, which would include a perfect storm of the Federal Reserve raising interest rates too fast, a “constitutional crisis” throwing U.S. government into turmoil and “a major geopolitical eruption.”

“You should prepare yourself for a recession perhaps as early as this year,” he said, pinning the chances of that at roughly 50%.

He said companies and hotels should “undergo rigorous stress tests” and “come up with adverse hypothetical scenarios” to gauge their preparedness for an economic downturns. He also noted it’s time to fight to protect margins.

“It’s important to renew focus on improving efficiencies on how to operate and improve productivity,” he said.

Baumohl said the hotels with the most aggressive and forward-thinking marketing, including heavy social media presences, will be better equipped to deal with a dip in business and leisure transient demand, which he expects to happen. He also noted property with “contingency plans in place” will be better equipped “when the time comes and the economy starts to slow.”

“You should at least have a plan well prepared to put into motion to help mitigate the risks from a sharp downturn or major geopolitical eruption,” he said.


  • Joel Ross July 5, 2018 11:29 AM Reply

    It is unclear where he gets his data. In fact cap ex by corporations rose 39% in Q1 and only 16% of the tax saving went to buybacks. Consumers balance sheets are is good shape with rising home values, rising 401K valuations, and rising wages. There are almost no more excessive mortgages that are beyond borrowers ability to pay, and while credit card debt is up, it is not at dangerous levels. GDP is expected to rise at over 4% and to continue rising at 3% -4% into early next year. Cap ex takes time to spend. Companies don't just flip a switch, so cap ex is just ramping up. It is highly probable the EU and Canada will resolve the trade issues in August as the EU is about to propose a solution to the auto tariffs and German auto companies have already said they would live with zero tariffs.

    The real issue for hotels is there is no idle labor and so hotel operating costs will exceed revpar growth and profit will decline as a result just as interest rates rise. Cash flow will be squeezed but this economist is way off reality.

  • Ginger Sullo January 28, 2019 6:34 AM Reply

    Joel's views don't back up as well. Though I also think the economist's views are too drama-driven for reality, they exaggerate.
    Clearly, starting with consumer credit, the credit spigot that spun out in spring 2015 exacerbated credit card debt AND personal loans to spend, spend, spend. From lower "middle class" to upper. Auto sector has stumbled in growth from '16.

    In fact, last Jan. '18 WSJ article stated we're at near record in personal debt, credit cards and loans.

    Regarding his myopic views on a "healthy" 4% GDP clip what he fails to state is the composition of this "gross" figure, e.g. PCE (personal consumption expenditures) don't correlate "healthy" with this this "great" growth from last year, abnormally low inflation rate for the breadth/output of our developed economy.

    Also strip out volatile food/energy plus MEAGER wage growth, e.g. .0.3% avg, and his views are a complete fallacy relative to GDP, the middle class on down has less spending power then ever, wage growth similar to 2000 compensation levels, hence the hotel category growth will be upscale, upper and luxe, not the lower hotel categories.

    The stock market is clearly propped up, psychological driven, with tech sector's value waning.

    The hotel sector is due to have a relative "similiar" year in '19 albeit lower profit margins due to higher consumer acq. spend costs higher labor costs, loyalty is ok, about 50% of the big brands, but massive worldwide RECORD debt of $220T announced a week ago with 60% in emerging mkts fed by private obvious in being quite

Comments that include blatant advertisements or links to products or company websites will be removed to avoid instances of spam. Also, comments that include profanity, lewdness, personal attacks, solicitations or advertising, or other similarly inappropriate or offensive comments or material will be removed from the site. You are fully responsible for the content you post. The opinions expressed in comments do not necessarily reflect the opinions of Hotel News Now or its parent company, STR and its affiliated companies. Please report any violations to our editorial staff.